<<@Vgn4U
says :
Thank you, Dr. Peterson! Thank you for speaking the truth of science. And thank you for hosting this immensely informative and helpful discussion with Dr. Grossman.
>>
<<@aprilu9785
says :
John Money was corrupt, and if John’s Hopkins hadn’t given him credibility we wouldn’t be in this situation as a society. How do we get our institutions to act on the best interest of the public.
>>
<<@nadiraslam5982
says :
I like Grossman but she does terrible at interviews. Umm, I..I... Ummm... it's hard to listen too. She needs to do better.
>>
<<@mitzitakes522
says :
I agree. While they’re at it, tell these people to inject kids with the chemicals that block burping and ffkatulemce in cows. How can it be right to protect animals from Experimentation and say it’s ok to do practice on humans!
>>
<<@Lisa-dy1fr
says :
Re-watching after the Tumbler Ridge shooting. Canadians need to wake up.
>>
<<@Rawdiswar
says :
Who is here after Tumbler Ridge?
>>
<<@p.j.simpkins8324
says :
You know that song "take my breath away " owwe whoo
>>
<<@Skelter13th
says :
Children are being butchered. Period. Anybody who tries to justify that for political ideologies are not only tragically flawed, they are flat out demonic. When they become adults, they can make those decisions for themselves... Not a single millisecond before.
>>
<<@deanomite420
says :
@phahr was it sarcasm or are you really still supporting trump? He's a wreck
>>
<<@theclau
says :
No more lost in transnation ❤
>>
<<@maureenkidd6629
says :
Who has deleted 11k comments? YouTube?
>>
<<@jonas-g
says :
If the basis for the APA is to solidify moral virtue in sound ethical guidelines to both standardize psychological methods and ensure that no harm is done … how could they logically or morally bolster this cancerous idea? And what else is needing to be question in the code of ethics/DSM?
>>
<<@Mags-w9f
says :
Oh my goodness I can’t believe I’ve only just stopped guilting myself enough to search this up! Mothers who understand the hell I am in, I’m literally sobbing & so close to giving in, my life has changed forever, they took my child away, weaponised my love as I said plz just slow down your only 13,I ❤you whatever & whoever you want to be let’s just slow down! Now I’m destroyed, I’m broken I’m alone & so, so sad ..But thank you for this I’ll read the comments later, I’m just so overwhelmed to hear this the understanding is just what I need, I’ve never been helped I’ve been suicidal but ignored by the services paid to help me god bless you Miriam🙏
>>
<<@simondamstra6433
says :
As far as I would be able to do so, I consider you perfectly immune to psychological and fysiological damage for the forseeable future.
>>
<<@davidm1149
says :
All of the clever cultural memes or fads I encountered in my teenage years I found to come from Hollywood. I'm also convinced that the "movie industry" (and music) is simply an extension of our wonderfully corrupt government, reduced to doing the bidding of corporate conglomerates. With this, we basically have a programming factory disguised as an 'entertainment industry'. We need to stop this epidemic somehow.
>>
<<@maryannmcleodevans2012
says :
How the discipline of psychiatry and surgery became so entrenched in gender ideology stems from social justice activism in the universities, regardless of discipline. Mix that emphasis of social justice nonsense with postmodernism, which seeks to transgress all binary systems of power, and you have the perfect storm of madness and butchery. Also, of course, white liberal mothers and dads can reduce their white privilege footprint by becoming parents of trans kids, especially if they’re divorced and the mother runs down the father. Horrific. Evil.
>>
<<@AaDaMa2026
says :
What about adult children, out of the home, who have gone down the deep depths of the web? How do we help them?
>>
<<@idaliakulik
says :
Absolutely love your work.
>>
<<@JaneHilton-u5h
says :
And now they all hide ...now the banning is starting ....and we have a pile of detransitioners and a cue of autistic individuals whom are still fixated still sold the lie still believing .... And GenderGP just waiting for the email for subscription .....I hope everyone of them goes to trial for unethical practice...we as parents will remain shattered and heart broken to the core
>>
<<@SalmanovGadzhimurad-pj9qq
says :
В 2010 году в Катаре прошли торжества по случаю достижения мощности производства СПГ в 77 млн тонн[2]. Катар является одним из крупнейших поставщиков СПГ в Индию (в апреле 2018 экспорт на 27,3% больше по сравнению с аналогичным периодом прошлого года). На начало 2020-х Катар запланировал очень серьезное расширение своих заводов СПГ — с текущих 78 млн тонн до 126 миллионов тонн[3]. Почти весь катарский СПГ — до 95 % — поставляется по долгосрочным контрактам в страны Азии. Препятствием для поставок на европейский рынок также является требование Катара не перепродавать поставленный газ .Я русский или американец ???game over для меня
>>
<<@desireephilpott2327
says :
I call this neo-eugenics. It's profound that so many are going for it. 😢 I pray for humanity 🙏
>>
<<@daniellet7715
says :
I do and have watched and enjoyed many of Jordan Petersons You tube discussions. This however was one I am strongly opposed to. Miriams got an Axe to grind but is Heroic in support of the young Gender Dysphoric or Gender confused Parents Feelings and I applaud her but is skewed in their Favour. Not much was said in support of the TGs plight. ....................I feel I must give some first hand evidence and feel strongly the need to do so in support of all involved. .................................................................................................................................................................................... I Do agree Some Definite RULEs need to be in place to Slow Down Pre-Pubescent and Teenagers that Identify feeling different or the Opposite to their Biological Birth Gender and starting HRT too early and definitely any Surgical Procedures. They do need to give it time to work through their feelings of Dysphoria and all the consequences and ramifications of Transitioning. Spend a few yrs maybe many until you can do your Homework, self reflect, meditate, talk to others goto support groups study up widely first. However, after listening to this discussion in its entirety, I cant help but notice it being Highly biased against those experiencing Gender Dysphoria and heavily supporting the Parental feelings. This doesn't take away from the Facts though that Transgenderism is a thing and occurs. FACT It is a small fraction of transitioning TGs that do revert, they were probably Gender confused rather than genuinely TG and got on the racing train and didn't look back or within enough. Here in Australia, there are many Gateways that slow the process down and gives a gender Dysphoric time to reflect and are heavily questioned in all the right ways. FACT No one is being LED to believe HRT is some miracle cure. No one is being LED to believe in all the proposed within this discussion of a great Euphoria after Transition. However in my experience and many others I know of its better than what was experienced prior for those that are genuinely TG and it has bought comfort inside and outside re Physical presentation. FACT Sexual function is not totally lost with the quality of Surgical procedures performed today. Some loss of sensation is there however this varies amongst those that go through GRS and Breast Augmentation. We don't do it primarily for sexual satisfaction rather to remove or change something we are not comfortable with. FACT John Money was cruel in and WRONG to do what he did with the Twin and may have forwarded some Transgender ideology, but he really had nothing to do with the MANY TGs before his time and nothing to do with many TGs being LED astray as portrayed in the discussion throughout his pre-history and I'm sure must have been since Humanity has existed it stands to reason. Watch the loosely told true story "The Danish Girl" movie which happened back in the 1930's. Probably one of the best movies I've seen which closely resembles the experiences and feelings of a TG. A good one for those struggling Parents to give some idea and insight of what we go through. Although I wouldn't recommend her GRS experience. FACT There are many TGs pre the internet or any publications as mentioned above that experienced Gender Dysphoria, transitioned and could not have been LED astray by social media or the Medical system. You don't wake up some day and decide oh lets become the opposite gender. Thats Ludicrous to think that. I'd never read anything of medical journals or saw anything relating to Transgenderism till I was well on my way to understanding my Dysphoria pre all the current modern age of the Internet. All this has come along since for me and many others. How do you account for that. .......................................... FACT It's sad that many Parents and Families of gender Dysphoric or the Gender Confused persons as outlined in the discussion go through Traumatic experiences. I truly felt for my Mother and did everything to try and help her relate but sadly couldn't get through to her Victorian conditioning. Sadly having been given an ultimatum of Rejection if I went through any change in my presentation had to move on. However you don't have to lose the person and their Love they just change and grow. yes i understand you lose the Son or the Daughter but They will be there if can only try support them as many parents with Open minds do. It doesn't have to be a traumatic experience or an embarrassment as described. I know of many who have had lovely experiences between Mother and father and Child. How many of those were presented above in the discussion. It was not well rounded and highly biased towards the Traumatic and Dramatically expressed so. Love is stronger than pride. Don't be too proud just open up and be Vulnerable and I believe your Child will be to you. If you truly Love your Children you Stand by them no matter what. As I would have stood by my Mother in support if she just could have let me. ............................................................................................................................................................................... .........FACT: A TG's Transition has its many loses and its many positives. You could lose your Mother and Fathers support and Love. I Hope and Wish you don't. Don't give up and listen to your Parents if your a younger gender Dysphoric. Take your time to analysis your self thoroughly before going through anything re changing. Def don't be LED astray by any Media personality or peer if they suggest you must transition pre puberty to Have a better outcome its simply not necessary. There is plenty of time DONT RUSH. You may find like many amongst the thread here that you are glad you changed your mind. You may find surrogate Parents or Parental Role models. I did. You will lose Friends but you will find new ones. You will struggle in the workplace during transition and be discriminated against endlessly during transition it takes a strong minded individual to get through it you will need friends who support you at least one V Good one. ........ ............ ... ... THEORY or FACT you Decide: I believe LIFE is a Mystery and Experience. One of Learning, Loving and living. Its about Growing and becoming a kinder more Caring Compassionate Person. Helping others as much as you can in every way that you can withing your ability. It wont always work out the way you want and sometimes its Painful, Hurtful uncaring and Troubling, this also has its Positives if you look for them. Where there is a negative there is a positive . Where there is a Positive there is a negative. The Universe or source or whatever you call it has your back and wants you to grow and will throw curve balls at you if don't work at Changing for the better. Ultimately, I Believe this is a Spiritual Journey Living within the confines of a Human Shell. BE-ING HUMAN BE-ING. I believe we've lived many Lifetimes ones which we are shut off from or else it would interfere with this one. And Just Maybe being TG is just one LIFE Experience where you get to Grow Exponentially as i have so far in my Many decades and I am still Learning, Loving and Living and so it goes on. .............................................................................................I am Content in my growth and my Life Experience so far except Losing my Elderly Mother who I dearly cared for. .............................................. Last note: ANYONE that would like any HELP or to Chat especially those Parents going through a difficult time I would Love to discuss anything you'd like. I will be as Candid and Honest as possible. If possible i hope I may Help with my content above Just ONE person it would have been worth the time and effort it took in writing this...
>>
<<@daniellet7715
says :
Re Identity. This is all Theoretical as expressed here not 'Experiential'. You haven't lived it or LIVE it so you can possibly Understand it. You can study it all you like read it in a book listen here and to any number of docos but you'll never be something by all that study. It's not in your Body Heart and Soul. The event re the twins and Dr Money has really no relevance to what a true Gender Dysphoric person goes through. That was a case where a baby was changed and suggested they were something they clearly weren't. Not someone who from early childhood who experiences genuine discomfort in who they are and what they are told they are but feels so distraught. Some withdraw from their parents and family and live an internal existence hiding in the closet having their confidence and self esteem eroded. Their trauma to say the least is REAL as the world expects you to be something you clearly to yourself are not. You may not know what you are but " YOU KNOW WHAT YOUR NOT". They have to survive so they, hide inside only having themselves to confide in not understanding why until they mature enough to learn to discover what may be thr Truth of their Identity. Afraid to reveal their feeling in case they are REJECTED. They have to fit into a black and white world so of course they will Identify as Black or white when really they are Purple or Green. My Understanding is its a third Gender being [ Transgendered Woman or Male ] somewhere along the colored spectrum not meeting the norm of either fully Male or Fully Female. There is so much more to this and you'd have to be very close to a TG to even come close to relating. I have had that experience. Dealt with it for over 50 years i can say I KNOW, i understand.
>>
<<@landonpackard8935
says :
I'm going to tell you ALL a little,....story,... that EVERYBODY NEEDS TO HEAR. Its a story about a guy named Guisseppe. So gather round kids, and pay very close attention to what I'm about to bestow upon you. Ready? Here it goes: Once upon a time, there was this famous bridge builder, who's name was Guisseppe. Now, Guisseppe wasn't just any ol' bridge builder, no sir. Ya see, Guisseppe was once known as the GREATEST bridge builder in the entire WORLD! People used to travel from far and wide just to look at and admire Guisseppe's amazing artistry and the quality of the architecture that went into every single bridge that he ever built. Guisseppe could build a bridge over or across anything, or to anywhere. Whenever there was a town or place, that needed a bridge to be built,...Guissseppe, is who they'd always call. NOBODY, could build a bridge near as beautiful nor as magnificent as Guisseppe could. Guisseppe was so world renowned for bein such a great bridge builder, that he couldn't go ANYWHERE without people knowing who he was. Everywhere he'd go, and every new town he'd come to, the townsfolk from miles around would always point and say, "Look, there's Guisseppe, the most famous and greatest bridge builder in the entire world!!". But then oneday,..... something utterly HORRIBLE and extremely DISPICABLE happened that involved Guisseppe, the world famous bridge builder. Just what was it, you may ask? Well, believe it or not, and as bad as I hate to repeat it, AND since EVERYONE needs to hear this story, I will tell you.....Ya see, what happened was, ....oneday,...our boy Guisseppe,.... ended up getting caught sucking a dick. Thats right,...Guisseppe, SUCKED A DICK!! Soooo, long story short, after Guisseppe was caught sucking somebody's dick, EVERYBODY COMPLETELY FORGOT about ALL of those magnificent bridges that Guisseppe had built. And he was no longer recognized or known for being the greatest bridge builder in the entire world again after that either. No sir. Now dont get me wrong here, Guisseppe was still recognized everywhere he went, just not as a world famous bridge builder anymore. In fact, his name wasnt no longer associated with anything that remotely even involved being a builder of bridges after that. Instead however, and still to this day, everyone just knows Guisseppe as being a COCKSUCKER!!! So now kids, incase some of you are struggling with finding, understanding, or wondering what the moral of this whole story here ☝🏿 about Guisseppe is, it's this: DON'T SUCK A DICK!!! DON'T BE A COCKSUCKER!!!
>>
<<@Jon-1005
says :
I truly hate John Money.
>>
<<@beckers4376
says :
Good old Agenda 2030, meeting those sustainability goals
>>
<<@MelindaPolet
says :
Extraordinary woman. Thank you Dr. Grossman. This is a travesty that I have seen coming as well. So glad and grateful for your work.
>>
<<@BTSmith-ig7bk
says :
"Gender affirming care" is a bigger euphemism than even" women's right to choose" is!
>>
<<@Carmen-q7i7z
says :
I believe people are being admitted to medical school with an agenda. Pedophiles are master manipulators. When there is a massive legal, political, educational and multi media machine pushing that ideology, they are being pushed to the front of the line.
>>
<<@JINX_ZIRS
says :
So trans is mostly treated as persona of objective experience’s. They would rather be the opposite sex than deal with their trauma that may still be there. No matter what you do to ovoid these issues in your life until you look at them and realize you need to change you have really no chance. When they mean by PRIDE it’s really only thing you have left with this woke ideology.
>>
<<@JINX_ZIRS
says :
So to prove there hypothesis they ignored the truth and forcing a family to go against nature 🤯
>>
<<@letteracura
says :
Grazie. <3
>>
<<@kozhinamin7717
says :
we need more proffesors like you. Please make more podcasts on this matter
>>
<<@Sense_Incensed
says :
There is NO difference in "brain chemistry". That is a lie. There's no difference in hormones, either. It's behavioral and victimization. Statistically, boys raised by single mothers or have a weak father or an absent father (even mentally/emotionally) will have an unhealthy hero worship of their mother. They will identify with the only stable parent or a strong mother. Why would she be strong? Because she might be the bread-winner (despite the father) or might have a dominant personality. They become easy prey for Predators. Then, there's the misguided selfish mother. Years ago, I watched an interview on Johnny Carson of a 60 year old author who claimed he "knew he was gay when he was 5 or 6", his earliest memories. How? His father travelled a lot due to his job and was absent from home. His mother got lonely and would take him to the movies with her, as if this little boy of 5 were her "companion" or "friend". They would be romantic films and she'd gush over the male actor in the film. She'd make inappropriate comments to her son about dreaming of being "carried away by the actor because he was so handsome and strong". After a couple of these films, he began to behave like his mother and have the same fantasies about being carried away by the strong handsome hero of the film. To me, that was child abuse. Isn't it obvious? He grew up thinking he preferred men and then, while he still had no father at home, he had his first "time" with an adult male; very likely targetted because his father wasn't around, he was groomed. It's obvious he also immitated his mother, became overly effeminate. Often, this is an exaggerated mimicking of the way a woman speaks or her mannerisms. He was such a mixed up man, he didn't recognize he was actually "conditioned". This is why these men think they were "born gay" because of a similar circumstance.
>>
<<@Peaceful.lizard365
says :
Trump saved the youth of America
>>
<<@autumnleaves2766
says :
Watching this discussion for a second time. One of the best interviews that Dr Peterson has ever done. Dr Miriam Grossman is a woman of integrity and courage, a real force to be reckoned with. Shame on all those so-called professionals who have been part of this gender insanity, from the leftist teachers indoctrinating the children in schools to the weak psychologists too lazy to question this evil ideology to the butcher surgeons happy to mutilate adolescents for life. They should all be jailed for what they've done, for crimes against humanity. It was all planned by the neo Marxists to damage the family unit, to lower birth rates in the west, to set family members against each other. It's all so evil, so despicable.
>>
<<@taytom6708
says :
One time I was babysitting a girl and she had her friends over and one of them told me she was non-binary, in 2016! I was in highschool and they were in middle school. I was appalled and didn't even know what it meant but she insisted I called her a 'them' like as if she was multiple people or a thing! So strange. I respected what she asked of me but it was such a weird thing that lead me to do a lot of research, I'm a mother now and will absolutely be homeschooling till a certain age. This social plague is such a strange phenomenon and needs to be studied! And it really is because of our phones.
>>
<<@jamescollins4641
says :
Thank-you! A refreshingly sane discussion in a growing sea of stupid...
>>
<<@danielmchale1716
says :
I'm a straight American and I want to thank you both for shedding light on this. There are only two genders!
>>
<<@venator3301
says :
If genitals don't define gender, how does removing them "affirm" it?
>>
<<@venator3301
says :
Dear Trans Community; Don't tell me I have to accept you for who you are when you couldn't even accept yourself for who you were.
>>
<<@BlueCactusbar
says :
I’m sorry but I can’t agree with her, she says that John Money had his own issues with, in her words, “Gender Dysphoria”, and that he hated his own genitalia, but that was not because he felt more like a woman, he was concerned about how he might be because of his own drunken violent father. There is surely a huge difference in not wanting to grow up and become like a person that you feared and possibly hated, than feeling like you’re in the “wrong body” and want to be a Woman, surely these are two completely different issues.
>>
<<@NOCTIDEPLAYSGAMES
says :
LGBTQ and Transgender idealism pushed on Children, and the calling people who call you out fascists & subsequently ruining or trying to ruin their lives, is the TRUE modern day Nazism. The radical LGBTQ movement is the 4th Reich. If they had the choice, they would exterminate every sensible Person on Earth, the People who disagree with them and call their movement hogwash.
>>
<<@unitedstatescitizen-m4q
says :
I would like to thank matt walsh for his flim "what is a woman " an awesome documentary on how people fall into such idiotic ideology .
>>
<<@MariaOdJezusa
says :
Thank You💚
>>
<<@JustineEuzinha
says :
I am trans without taking hormones.
>>
<<@chantelibra5160
says :
Traumatized parents that are demonised for wanting to protect their kids from this evil, without anyone to turn to because all the so-called experts are complicit in the harm. It is a sheer living hell.
>>
<<@Kimberly-w1k
says :
Why would they do this?! If you knew how beautiful and kind my dear son is to me and a multitude of others who have been blessed by his goodness. Unfortunately and sadly, he has been targeted and greatly confused by this extreme and insidious movement and is now in the process of transitioning. Those who are behind this cunning and wicked movement are also advising its followers/victims to admonish and turn away from loving family members who do not convert to their way of thinking. The leaders of the movement have created a sick distorted process of evangelization focused on the must vulnerable.
>>
<<@Kimberly-w1k
says :
Thank you!
>>
<<@bleeepbloopglon
says :
1:33:56 *makes eye contact in sync, smiling confused, and giggle insanely* got it.
>>
NEXT VIDEO
>>