<<@prabhurr8916
says :
Pinker squandered his reputation by sitting with quack sad-guru
>>
<<@EmmanuelZiki-c3n1l
says :
Professor Pinker is a goat!
>>
<<@rsatishm
says :
This kind of discussion has been held on and off even in earlier times. The problem of disconnect is that the experiences Sadhguru is talking about happen when the mind is dropped, and dropping the mind is not as easy as dropping a bag. There are several methods and practices aimed at achieving this state. Once the mind is dropped, one experiences the true consciousness, often referred to as chitta. The disconnect here is that science uses the mind to prove things and understand the nature of reality, whereas spirituality is about transcending or dropping the mind and directly experiencing one's own true self.
>>
<<@sushilverma3770
says :
Mr Steven pinker came to win the debate not to discuss..
>>
<<@kunalchawathey
says :
Sadhguru tries to explain the fragrance of a rose to someone who's never seen a flower. Even within a few months of meditation, one's experiences transcend way beyond what contemporary science can fathom.
>>
<<@daredreamdo
says :
The heart system develops first in an embryo before the spine and brain. Is the heart the most important for memory and consciousness?...๐โ
>>
<<@jeroentenhoeve1086
says :
The little pinkler knows about life realy stuns me. He knows a lot about little. It always surprises me the scientist offer up their life to so little. Thank you so much thanks to science we know a little better how things work. Still , stop telling me how to go about in my life. I will never stop seeing the miracle in things. They started with a forboden of the word god and now the word miracle . Children little children fighting over nothing. Please lead us to understanding not more divisiion.
>>
<<@freejo4000
says :
idiots want consciousness to be a thing they can study in a petri dish or test tube... super duper idiotic
>>
<<@nextari
says :
Pinker is such a damned fool. His insufferable face is riddled with doubt. He's simply on his last hurrah to sell a million books. Put it to rest. ๐คก
>>
<<@AsankaSampath-g9x
says :
โค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธโค๏ธ๐๐๐๐๐ฑ๐ฑ๐ฑ๐ฑ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐
>>
<<@MillerLandSteward
says :
I wish this Scientist just had a direct experience of Infinite.
>>
<<@MillerLandSteward
says :
Sahdguru is on another level of Wisdom.
>>
<<@Loopysage108
says :
This feels like hearing a 2 dimensional character debate a 3 dimensional character on length, width and depth. lol
>>
<<@mikepfeiffer74
says :
YOU are not a part of weeee
>>
<<@mikepfeiffer74
says :
lol yes it's so natural to the words of Saud Guru feels good and whenever Brainiac talks it, it's just so sad and painful to listen to
>>
<<@akknellai3165
says :
I know for sure science can never catch up spirituality. Science can't give clarity. You ask 100 best nutritionist on egg or milk benefit to human body. They will stand divided in their opinion that is what the brain. Contrarily in Pazhani 1000s of year ago Sidhar Bogar created idol with 9 poisions like mercury, aresenicum but that made into a medinal value producut whatever contacted the Lord Murugan idol. Certainly science cant give the bliss, ecstasy that spirituality brings and it is supreme and unparalleled. One will stop questioning, the moment he experiences. Conciousnes is realization of the self even while confined in the human body. Sri Aurobindo says science is an ignorant child of the spiritual mother.
>>
<<@12NinjaSkiLL
says :
We know it doesn't exist... science should never conclude what we don't know shouldn't exist. That guy isn't a true scientist. Instead he has beliefs that he imposes as an argument. Weak.
>>
<<@Hanumandarshan14
says :
Professor Looks very tense, He should calm down๐
>>
<<@kathiduran9583
says :
Always amazing how, even 2yrs after this talk prof. Steven would be considered the PMC and he still is selling this idea that the US somehow provided peace to the world. Itโs amazing how he missed the barbarity of the U.S. did the past 100 years but it doesnโt affect the PMC so thatโs not unusual ๐คท๐ปโโ๏ธ
>>
<<@Bobsaccount123
says :
God isnโt a person or power. Itโs energy and intelligence according to science. Weโre part and parcel of same energy and intelligence which govern this whole universe- Dr Deepak Chopra. Our brain doesnโt produce consciousness which comes from cosmic consciousness.
>>
<<@SanctifiedLady
says :
1:15:35 Sadguru โค
>>
<<@SanctifiedLady
says :
47:44 Sadguru starts cooking here โค๐
>>
<<@rm2732
says :
What an interesting dialogue. Absolutely fascinating to listen to both perspectives. Thank you Professor and Guru Ji.
>>
<<@harbiyeli35
says :
may Steven Pinker find God soon
>>
<<@rohitdalai1965
says :
Trying to be oversmart
>>
<<@rohitdalai1965
says :
Unnecessary too much talking just to stall the debate
>>
<<@chrismack-ig7tb
says :
โLost in Logicโ - so true and a clever mouse trap. A miracle is the totality of the event. Acceptance facilitates gratitude, the most effective antidote to the current mental health crisis of this timeline. This is a matter of fact, that only the mouse trap can ignore.
>>
<<@MrCMVikram
says :
Being in anesthesia is not turning off consciousness. It is the same as going to sleep. The brain cells are temporarily turned off. Consciousness is something else - far more than what the professor thinks.
>>
<<@MrCMVikram
says :
All scientists can do is to study how nature works and try to explain it. But a scientist cannot create a seed. A scientist cannot create life. He can only study and explain how a human is born from nothing to everything. The problem with science is that they think they know everything, but they do not. Even the Big Bang is just a hypothesis. No one knows what happened and how we are here - why we are here and where do we go from here.
>>
<<@as_positive_as_a_proton
says :
Nice conversation
>>
<<@JardineKarate1
says :
Sadhguru has mastered the art of using many words to say nothing of value.
>>
<<@BillBrushwork
says :
Or doesnโt know
>>
<<@BillBrushwork
says :
Like how much of what sadhguru know canโt stand up to what is true according to whatever kind of samadhi this person has been in
>>
<<@BillBrushwork
says :
Why did โsadhguru jagidisha vasudevaโ like lose this argument ๐
>>
<<@bojanstamenkovic2192
says :
What an arrogant jerk ๐
>>
<<@thegarage1001
says :
Iโm appalled by the sheer arrogance. Is this really what our universities are producing? Listening to this professor speak is nauseatingโit makes me seriously question the ethics underpinning our education system.
>>
<<@theotrman1
says :
Weird Sadguru has to have brain surgery after meeting this constructed robot-Pinky....
>>
<<@louiseabernathy
says :
I USED to listen to Prof. Pinker when studying psychology (for my own learning, not as a degree) until I learned HE IS severely implicated IN THE EPISTEIN FILES!! With all my respect, Pinker I do not care for your understanding of things. Sadhguru, as always, bringing clarity and wisdom. Thank you Sadhguru!
>>
<<@tompommerel2136
says :
This debate is a superb example of what Sadguru has said all along about what happens when an intellect is so sharp and excluding (& the person identifies with it) at the expense of their humanity.
>>
<<@grantsmith6613
says :
Pinker: my book says good is living instead of dying and maximizing well being ect ect because thatโs what people generally agree on. Then immediately explains how some people think the exact opposite ๐. The people of the French Revolution used the exact same logic and reasoning that those of the American enlightenment used and look where it got them.
>>
<<@513ErinG
says :
Sadhguru was not once dismissive or condescending in his approach to describing how miracles can be viewed however the comment " Admiration for taking dirt seriously, it's not a miracle, hats off to you" was disrespectful and passive aggressive statement to make. SMH ๐ค
>>
<<@susanl.mcintosh396
says :
pinker is so sad. what a cage he has built for himself. he has a long long way to go.
>>
<<@mysticintraining7129
says :
O what a genetic modified cog.
>>
<<@mmkhara1143
says :
Amazing ๐
>>
<<@JeetBrahma-q2d
says :
This debate is a miracle
>>
<<@MrJontyPatel
says :
It's amazing that the host asks Prof. Steven one question about the title and he goes on with almost a 12-13minutes response. Prof. wants attention and sounds like he apparently knows everything. Prof. needs meditation desperately; just my two cents. Also, the professor don't know the power of NOTHINGNESS; The power of SHIVA; can only be felt if he truly sits down and meditate. He will see miracles.
>>
<<@timothygibbens9796
says :
Sadhguru in the Epstein files?
>>
<<@Pebam777
says :
as a student of linguistics i can see a lot of people misunderstood Prof Steven.
>>
<<@SomTugnait
says :
Non physical identity is the creation of All physical energy.. Consciousness is not physical but that created physical world ... Bhram created the universe .. Energy created something which is convinced by human mind because it is impressionable.. comes by our limited input totally governed by outside influence...
>>
<<@BhanwariDevi-y7d
says :
Sadhguru ji๐๐๐
>>
NEXT VIDEO
>>