Bless Jordan, he needs to improve his interview skills, less about his opinion and more about the specialist’s thinking and less interrupting and going off in different tangents which makes for a scattered presentation, all over the place and nowhere. Drilling down on Hamas unique style of urban warfare. John does his best to convey his points despite the interruptions
@Taylor-xc6pr Says:
This war expert was imbedded with the IDF and interviewed Bibi. But sure, he’s objective.
@delowarabegum7796 Says:
This is the same guy who said America going after the talilban and the saddam regime after the attacks on 9-11 were needed, yeah sure the outcomes of the war on terror has not been disastrously overstated, these same experts have led us to never ending wars in the Middle East, and everyone on the comments keeps thinking their the experts who comes up with these brilliant ideas that always end up turning out to be not so brilliant…
@Lord_Inquisitor_Ferrus_Eisen Says:
I know John Spencer personally. Ultra nice, humble, but an absolute genius.
@hendibramble7160 Says:
No one pay atention to Saudi Arabia and Qatar?
@brandonlee3381 Says:
Well said 😀🎉😮😊
@Jessicad9304 Says:
I love what Dr Peterson said about people not understanding evil and it leads to sympathizing with perpetrators. it’s so true.
@pisowiec Says:
❤❤❤❤
@BennyCouto-rk2jo Says:
ask yourself why Hamas recorded what they did on October 7th you can watch a lot of it everyone should try to watch it to understand what we are fighting against just listen to their own words
@treeglass Says:
No. THERE IS NO DEFEATING THEIR IDEOLOGY.
TO THEM, IT'S NOT A LAW.
TO THEM, IT'S NOT AN IDEOLOGY.
TO THEM, IT'S NOT A FEAR.
TO THEM.... IT'S THE LITERAL WORD OF GOD. TO THEM, GOD HAS TOLD THEM THAT IT DOES NOT END until the VERY END.
@pattichapman7296 Says:
I just watched this again. I was able to listen, stop & really think about what was being said, digest it then continue the video. WOW!! Two intelligent men, one asking GREAT questions, the other giving GREAT answers!! Too bad most people could watch & listen to this & still believe that Israel is the aggressor trying to commit genocide!! When people say that to me I tell them that IF Israel wanted to do that they would have started the war 10.08.23 & carpet bombed Gaza back into the stone age before they sent any troops into Gaza. After that any time they saw movement they would have called in an air strike before they did anything else. Plus they wouldn’t have let ANY food or aid of ANY kind into Gaza. Israel is fighting the most compassionate war I’ve EVER seen. They care more about the Gazan people than anyone else!! Thank you so much Dr. Peterson & John Spencer for taking 2 hours out of your lives to do this for us!! As of 12.01.24 it has 387K views. That’s amazing. Thanks again gentlemen. God Bless you both. 🙏🏼🌈❤️🕊🐾
@mariavanzetti6896 Says:
If Hamas is ready to sacrifice their own civilian, people, women and kids, then, one should ask oneself, how much are they ready to sacrifice other people, without any empathy or feelings whatsoever? Young followers, masses on Campuses which are now protesting and walking daily for them, promoting their death cult agenda without knowing what and who they really are? It is dreadful and appalling just thinking about that.
@aaronjohnsheppard5745 Says:
To quote Mr. Spencer: It doesn't matter what their religion is“. Religion is the only reason why these groups are waging wars and implementing terror attacks all around the world. When Mr. Spencer said that in his history and study of war he never saw "human sacrifice strategy.". All of that is predicated on how their hardline fundamentalist clerics have interpreted their religion. If there was no specific religion, which they so blindly follow, there would be no wars in the 21st century at all, and Mr. Spencer wouldn't need to go and do his PhD or Master-Studies on urban warfare. I would rather Mr. Spencer do a PhD in Horticulture; That would be magnificent. But that is just a poor man's dream; Alas, we humans have to go kill and maim one another, and I never understood why or for what.
@roeko10 Says:
In the last few decades there are plenty of urban wars because many of them include radical Muslims, who uses their people as a shield, this is the mentality
@shrifreedom Says:
32:35 "From me, as my expertise, this is where we have definitely reached that point in the war against Hamas in Gaza, where there is this "How do you defeat an ideology?" (that's for sure) "I work in the world of strategy and war, but I am fighting on a daily basis people who did their PhDs in counter-insurgency and counter-terrorism saying that you are creating more enemy or more terrorists than you are killing." (right, right, because of the military, even if there is a short-term victory that doesn't mean that you are ensuring the long-term victory, quite the contrary. Do you think that's happening in Gaza?) "Its bullocks. It’s a fallacy of thinking. And I think its anti-intellectual." (ok. explain why.) "It's like saying you cannot remove Hitler and the Nazi regime or dismantle its military base 'cause you will further radicalize the German population who believe in the Nazi ideology."
@fucanaoasis2000 Says:
Unbelievable analysis
@joshuabarnett7128 Says:
I'm a Trump voter who has been convinced by the ethnic cleansing arguments. Regarding the justification for using bunker buster bombs, I would be more inclined to believe this if there were more evidence of they know a military bunker is underneath. The one time that video evidence emerged of Hamas in civilian infrastructure was at the beginning of attacks on hospitals. There was one AK-47 and the rest was fairly typical hospital equipment, yet this was deemed as justification for taking out hospitals. I found that wholely unconvincing.
Additionally, the targeting of drinking water infrastructure and the vetting of aid (to the degree that it constituted withholding it) paired with statements by Israeli officials that the creation of a humanitarian crisis would aid the war effort, have led me to believe that war crimes are indeed being perpetrated.
@zartic4life Says:
Collective punishment like preventing electricity, food and shelter for two million that are trapped while being bombed with missiles are blatant war crimes not Hamas indoctrination Professor.
@BooglestationTermoil Says:
Human Sacrafice Stratergy : Hannibal Directive. The Tunnels main function was contraband, smuggling in live stock, Food, electric components, even Marmaleade n Sugar, cement were banned during the blockade.. Back in 2004 CNN journalists even went in to the tunnels to document it.. After years of ¨Mowing the Lawn¨ .. they became hide outs from continuous experimental air strikes.. eventually turning into weapon infiltration routs and deposits used to defend themselves from the occupying forces..the testing of Hbsora, A.I Human killing machine developed by iSRL was labeled as their first effective A.I weapon in 2021, a¨the massassasination factory¨ they boasted its effectiveness.. ( The 30,000 number is based on A.I ¨Lavender¨ average calculation using cellphone contacts ) .. .. Gaza is only 40Km x 8 Km wide,, it´s Tiny.. a tight conglomerate of 2 Million incarcerated human beings used by the regime f to conduct weapon development and new ways for killing humans.. iSRL arms Sales are in the Bull Market right now.. The reason they are broadcasting the obliteration with so much emphasis is because it´s being used as an advertising campaign..
@letsnotmincewords Says:
This in-depth conversation clarified a lot for me.
@ukaszwojtalik8198 Says:
Hanibal canibal baby eater😅 small joke😅 both sides are now hateing extremly each other but... look for the root of this evil and development ideas for this conflict on both sides... it looks like long planned conflict for me and development was fully controled by sabotage and disinformation and at this stage both sides are at stage of total war ...
@ltzmin Says:
This is the single greatest video to understand the current conflict and others. This plus a good history lesson on the region and you are pretty much vaccinated against the nonsense that surrounds this war and the Jihadist horrendous tactics
@almog1910 Says:
Great hearing from an expert in the field!
@sofiaGUT Says:
Maybe I'm not suppose to say it but professionaly speaking, speakinh from expiriance, this is 100 percent accurate. Hamas made an invasion on israel and unfortunately uses human shields that support its propaganda.
@mehdikhalil1507 Says:
Have Jordan ever interviewed anyone from the other side? Like there are many people who speak facts from the other side of this conflict, why aren’t they being interviewed? This really sounds like nazi germany only interviewing people who say jews are bad.. they will only speak their theories of how jews are less human than they are. Which just makes the narrative they support seem like it’s the right thing.
certainly the kids being killed everyday in gaza are not bad, not terrorists.. international law is very clear, do not kill civilians, and the israeli terrorist forces are not doing anything but that. Interview some people from the other side, at least give yourself a chance to be remembered as someone who cared about justice and truth and pursued them (like you used to promote)! There’s never a judge listening to only one part of a conflict, and any judge who does that, we can all agree that they are incompetent, don’t be the incompetent judge!
@MarcusHeron-fb8bi Says:
Fantastic Interview which helps dispel all the do-gooder retóric around Israel-Gaza conflict being spread by a misguided left that don’t want to listen to the whole story.
@Aleksamson Says:
No studies? I'm pretty sure that Israel has bunch of studies, extensive body of work. Just not published or even classified. They've been battling in urban warfare since 1948.
@NancySwass Says:
Very educational. Thank you
@NancySwass Says:
Peace to you, Israel.
@vyner5727 Says:
almost no negative comments. Crazy!
Almost like this fact based talk has them at a loss for words.
@vyner5727 Says:
We are so screwed!
Suicidal empathy!
@ro0140 Says:
One thing to know and keep in mind is that the allies during WW2 decided to kill the nazi childeren soldiers even after capturing them because they determind that those kids where too indoctrinated. That deprogramming those kids which would throw themselves towards tanks and soldiers without fear seemed to be impossible.
One thing that during WW2 didn't occur was that there was no social media showing the results and horror of the attrosities of bothsides unless is was approved by the Ministerie of War.
@AaronKeeghan Says:
The world truly doesn't want to accept the reality of what is under their nose.
@tensaijuusan4653 Says:
Thank god the You Tube, Google etc platforms can't shut you down Dr. Peterson. For the little people, our comments are routinely censored when they don't fit the anti-Israel , pro-"woke" narrative.
@stevemills1481 Says:
This is probably one of the best videos I have seen. I wish I could have been there and asked a few questions myself e.g What's you opinion/analysis of UNRWA, I would have liked for you to have gone into more depth....do you think they are complicit with Hamas or just naive, why have we been funding a RELIEF organisation for 75yrs!?. What about the irresponsibilty of the media in all this e.g Do you believe the BBC have an agenda? Are the UN past their sell by date? What are the implications for Israel in the upcoming US elections...what can they expect if the Dems stay in power?
@MarkusAxunIllianus Says:
The amount of cut offs from Jordan Peterson in this one is hard to take. You have a uniquely knowledgable person here. And he cannot say what he wants because he gets cut off after every one point and cannot elaborate on it.
Don't get me wrong, criticism on a high level. It was good. But it could have been much better.
@AlbertXhota Says:
Ye ye, we know it all now. YOU ATR THERE TO STEAL!
@ДмитрийДепутатов Says:
Williams Timothy Davis Amy Martinez Helen
@RebelRushB Says:
Thank you
@SherriKish Says:
I would add that this war has a spiritual component which is that demons can enter human bodies and carry out the devils evil schemes. Oct 7 was inhumane
@hl5hl5 Says:
Egypt is not economically strong, and they don't want to be part of the war. Egypt has said this publicly. Israel designates safe areas and then attacks them. So much of this information is not accurate.
@hl5hl5 Says:
I understood the tunnels were built not just for warfare but were used to get things into Gaza (the occupied territory which had many restrictions on--so supplies and products etc..) Also, the tunnel system appears to be extensive. They weren't purposely built under certain civilian structures. Gaza isn't that big. Where were the fighters supposed to go?
@es3t Says:
I see censorship is working here still. So sad.
@nizanklinghoffer4620 Says:
People aren't persuaded by evidence, they're persuaded by pain. Here the pain is in the future, and so people are lenient with the satanic religion that is afflicting the west.
@veraleandro Says:
They are human shields, thats the true and they are not worried about the war rules,and his own people, so wy Israel have to follow the rules? Its not fair
@csal-nogero Says:
Thank you for the facts!
@PatriciaOReilly-Southee Says:
Ignorance at the highest level.
@sharonhainesNumber1Red Says:
They are going after the Jews because they are God’s chosen people. It’s not just because they are successful. And by the way, they are successful because they are God’s chosen people.
LATEST COMMENTS