Of course a short about Marxism on Jordan Peterson’s channel is full of completely ignorant comments from uneducated twats. Go read the communist manifesto and other Marxist writings and you’ll realize how stupid and uneducated you people are. Not saying you have to agree with it, but the ignorance from this comment section reeks. Insane that people have information at their finger tips, yet they’re too stupid and lazy to do actual research. They’d rather be spoon fed the lies they’ve heard their entire lives. Sad.
@Josué-j8s Says:
Read your bibles, Jesus says in them:
"Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law." Mathew 10:34-35.
Conflict was not invented by Marx lmao. There has always been conflict, Jesus said early christians would be in conflict with non christians, in fact, that became the norm for christianity, to attack other cultures for conversion. There have always been slave and serf revolts. Marx noted that conflict was inherent between classes in capitalism and predicted people would make revolutions because of that, he didn't create them. For anybody thinking Marx created class, race and gender conflict, really? You think in earlier civilizations there was not any conflict between groups? That's the history of humanity, don't blame a 19th century intellectual that you probably don't know enough about for them
@JasonGoodfellow Says:
We're Marx around today, he'd correct Peterson, rebuke him, then probably challenge him to a pistol duel (he challenged some guy once). At this point I'm sure Peterson would break down and cry (which is fine, but goes against the whole angry white guy in his 60's persona).
@UncleLumbago-rdr2 Says:
Well when you realize that the big three OWN 95% of the S&P. Then they do dirty things to manipulate the fall of businesses so that they own and control even more but their sstatus is well above mine. Tell me again about this hierarchy. LMAO 😂 I dont think so. I know a secrete! Love you BESTIE!
@leninistefrancophonefache Says:
I don't have the ammount of confidence this man has for talking so much in public about something he clearly doesn't know about. He should perhaps read something else than the manifesto, but honestly he didn't even understood this simple propaganda pamphpet, so i doubt he would be able to wrestle with work like anti dühring or even the core of dialectic.
@MichaelFerraro-bt4ig Says:
Everyone is oppressed because of money. The more one has, the more one has to lose. The more one has, the more likely one is to do absolutely anything to avoid losing it.
@The_Crab_Whisperer Says:
That suit! 🤩
@sv650ssuzuki2007 Says:
Marx was a spoiled brat. My best guess is his father imposed a budget onto the guy and this budget then made Marx bitter and resentful.
@mikeyerian2562 Says:
Another episode of Peterson repackaging something everyone knows. Seriously why do we think this guy is a genius?
@UlteraBurns Says:
The problem with oppresser and oppressed is anyone can apply it to themselves but then their version of who is oppressor and who is oppressed is completely different. Generally, the only oppressor and oppressed that really applies generally is through evil business practices and corrupt governments.
@amorfati4752 Says:
Karl Marx wasn't the first to do that! You should know this well, you've read Nietzsche.
@michaelcrane3646 Says:
And this is even present in the climate scam, where the oppressor is humanity, and the oppressed is "the Planet."
@782YKW Says:
Marx was right.
@davidvincent8929 Says:
NO DRUGS NO DRUGS NO NUDITY NO SCREWING GIRLFRIEND IN WHITEHOUSE BEHIND WIFE'S BACK.
@nomadr1349 Says:
Marx is probably the most evil mind this planet ever saw.
@lanolinlight Says:
"Envy" is often the convenient scapegoat of colonists, exploiters and other profiteering oppressors--the ol' "They hate us cuz they ain't us" argument. From Detroit to Gaza. Sober analysis of an economic system and how it can foster injustice is jettisoned in favor of a virtue contest in which capitalism always judges itself the winner by a landslide.
@davidthomas1918 Says:
Truth
@tracimetcalf3374 Says:
Karl Marx did not create that dichotomy. It was always there. Workers organizing is what created the ɓiggest Middle class America ever had . The Regan revolution destroyed it.
@andyc9902 Says:
Karl Marx was one bitter man . Because he didn't own any company
@greyngreyer5 Says:
Jokes tell themselves. My fav one is people who are for communism tend to be anti-semitic. Except the problem is that Karl Marx was Jewish.
@HoneyBadgerTexas Says:
Marxs and his "Theories " from hell. Ironically guys like Marxs demand to have a nice lunch and a soft bed daily. Usually did not feel empathy for the working class but total manipulation of poor minds facing adversity. Look what Castro did to Cuba. Now we have Venezuela and on the past East Germany, The oppressed people by their dictators.
@3-6-9-6-3 Says:
Those who covet are as wicked as those who hoard. Same coin.
@l.z.2315 Says:
Peterson nema pojma o komunizmu.Oligarhija na vrhu(robovlasnici,feudalci ,kapitalisti) oduvjek zivi bogato na grbaci radnicke klase .
Komuniza je teznja ka besklasnom drustvu u ekonomskom pogledu.
@sbolfing Says:
Marx was a moron. The best compliment that be given was everything he wrote was based on his narrow world view, based solely on 19th Century Europe
@johnvoices4087 Says:
Carl Marx lived his entire life with another man, a very rich man, in that man's house. He never had a job his entire life. He was a manchild that was coddled, very privileged, most likely gay, and also the bottom of the gay relationship. It's quite clear where he got his ideas.
@nathanielknight1838 Says:
yeah, then they send a bunch of kids to be reeducated by the peasantry, killed the intellectuals or anyone wearing glasses and communism just has never been tried the right way you know? Because obviously the same exact consequence every single time is just a coincidence
@BillSettles Says:
Thank you for what you do
@BillSettles Says:
I used to say that YouTube can be a tool for the fatherless
@beebell7288 Says:
Absolutely 💯
@malcolmthorne9779 Says:
Oppressor and oppresser. Pure and sinner.
Whether it's religion or political ideology, the ones who traffic in simplistic black and white notions of virtue are unrealistic and doomed to fail.
Marx did get more things right than christianity did, I'll give him that much.
Still a deeply flawed and technically incomplete ideology that doesn't work in its pureform.
There's a reason why the most succesful nations on the planet use som kind of fragmented, hybridized version of socialism.
And treats it and other ideologies and -isms as tools to be used as they are useful and dismissed or disposed of when they are not.
A true statesman, a true leader, serves his people and nation first and above all else.
Even if he has to defy gods and prophets to do so.
Partial socialism has use.
Pureform socialism does not work.
Religion had use, but we've far outgrown its usefulness.
And its drawbacks and unforgivable barbarity are now intolerable and a threat to our very future.
Anyone who clings to religion is a traitor to humanity at this point.
And in religion I include the woke cult and its sects.
They too are a threat against humanity itself.
@r4_in_space Says:
As he's explaining Marxism, the thing just keeps getting worse by each sentence.
@Not_Sure-2020 Says:
And the communist government then took control of all economic power and created a country where nobody except the government had anything so none of the people could be envious of each other. And they all lived happily ever after (well, the ones that lived maybe).
;)
@prostoname5338 Says:
lol, haven’t seen a worse take on Marx for while. Peterson is such an L dude, I cannot believe that someone with PHD has such a low reading comprehension.
@TheStemos Says:
Stop reading the "manifest" of Marx. It is invalidised version of the "Capital". And YES the history is repeatedly proved the one simple trouth. The "good" opressor, who is morally and humanly good to the opressed, is doomed to be consumed by other opressors who doesnt give a shit about moral 'stupidities.
So YES the structure of capitalism needs to have a mechanism to coserve the balance between the wolves and the sheep.
@lanabanana6849 Says:
Such a good description
@EM-bp5zv Says:
Taylor Swift is oppressing.
@anthonykology1728 Says:
the ideology of teenagers...
@wvglitter7761 Says:
"The LOVE of money is the root of all evil."
@miamorhardstyle Says:
Even a child could tell you there's more to people than class... there are countless ways people end up different from each other especially over a lifetime.
What's even more ironic is that every time they've tried communism you end up with a despotic dictatorship worse than the monarchy they hate so much
@julietnanto9545 Says:
Love interview with Katherine...Respect you please do not wear that jacket.. Love
.a fan!!!
@damonpayne3018 Says:
But Karl Marx had that Gyatt
@baumulrich Says:
arguably, classical Marxism isn't that dangerous, as it just takes a few years for this ideology to reveal it's failures.
the real danger is neomarxism, where it's extended to race gender and whatever they want next. that is a never ending struggling ever and ever more destroying society. But it's going for 60 years now and it seemingly is getting stronger and stronger the more it spreads.
@gateguardian44 Says:
The number of Marxists on my social media is astonishingly high and it concerns me. Greatly...
@roundedges2 Says:
Marx thought that all value and wealth was the result of just blending physical objects he called capital e.g. land, machinery with labour. "Just give labor the tools and they will produce the same wealth." How silly.
He was completely oblivious of the huge contribution of innovation, the never-certain gambles of investment involved, and astute management to the wealth creation process.
Because he was never a manager or entrepreneur. Kinda shallow/dumb, really.
@manuelmartinati84 Says:
Absolutely not! Marx says that all societies in history had oppressive structure EVEN the capitalist one! But according to Petersen every revolution should be avoided!!!!
@Seafarer64 Says:
The more I hear about Marx, the more I realize he was quite the simpleton.
@SwissCheese112 Says:
let me correct you from the very beginning, Karl Marx didn't split the world into oppressor and oppressed, he just put into words what had already been the case for thousands of years. Unions existed before Marx, peasant revolts for better pay, land ownership, and freedoms existed before Marx. So please, stop making socialism out to be some 19th century invention by Marx.
@R3l3ntl3sss Says:
It was an interesting observation for sure, however he got lost in his own narrative. Niche explained it all much better
@moonshineman5691 Says:
It's not even that simple. Marx also stated that the lumpenproletariat ("the ragged proletariat", a term which he used to refer to the beggars, street performers, the unemployed, prostitutes, "bohemians" or artists, vagabonds and so on) would never achieve class consciousness and will probably side with the capitalists and are thus useless to the revolution. So even Marx himself didn't have the heart to care for the actual poor, but rather saw the industrial working class as a leverage through which the communist revolution could manifest itself.
LATEST COMMENTS